Jan 11th, 2007
The Apple iPhone: Music phone or smartphone? Part III
“Cool, no hard hard keys!” versus “Are you kidding? No keyboard?”
First, I’m not deluded enough to think the iPhone is the holy grail of devices. They have a lot in their favor in the US, but they don’t have a smooth ride like they did with the iPod.
If you read the US blogs and tech papers, the iPhone is best thing since the personal modem. Glowing headlines like Apple Waves its Wand at the Phone, where David Pogue equates Apple to a fairy godmother, to “It’s Expected, but it’s Stunning” from the SF Chronicle.
But if you read what the Europeans and Asians are saying, this is cool, but not worth all the hype. Russell Buckley even says it’s just a music phone. Then there’s the LA Times story: “In Japan, Barely a Ripple”, which is saying that all these features (plus mobile payments) have been available in Japan for 2+ years already. (But come on, they haven’t thrown out cumbersome soft keys in exchange for full-face, multi-touch screens, have they?)
So, what is it? Is it just a music phone?
Apple’s foray into mobile reminds me of Apple’s iPod launch. In 2001 they were not the first music player on the scene by any means. But when they released it they blew away the competition — the click wheel, the price point for massive 4GB storage compared to the 48MB competitors reset the pricing across the category and they nailed PC syncing.
Fast forward a bit to 2006. After 17 quarters of consecutive growth iPod sales declined the last 2 quarters. US papers merely list other digital music players and the lack of replacemnt batteries as the reason. But, Tomi Ahonen, in an article in The UK Guardian says the decline is due to mobile phones that double as music players. That may be true outside the US for iPod sales, but I have to doubt how much it holds true here. (And I’d love it if someone knows of US studies to that effect.)
Considering that so-called “music phones” are the next wave in the US — in part, I’d say the iPhone is the next natural bump in an iPod line that would otherwise just continue to shrink (where else can you go without integrating mobile/voice/etc.?)
However, unlike 2001’s intro of the iPod, or 1984’s introduction of the Macintosh, Apple is not competing against a fledgling mobile market — neither in it’s domestic or international markets. They’re competing on an international stage of existing players, some of whom have poured a lot of years and research into mobile UI and user behavior. Apple has got to compete on their own merits through innovation, and will have to prove their mobile offering abroad.
The problems with the current crop of music phones
If you bought a $100+ phone in 2005 or later, it surely came with MP3 capability, and probably bluetooth. But these are lousy replacements for a dedicated music player, iPod or not. Chances are you have an MP3 capable phone but still cling to an iPod for your tunes. The proprietary headphones are merely passable and the fact that you can’t use your favorite headphones is annoying, but what’s worse is the inability to create or manage a playlist. You cannot scan ahead through a long podcast or audiobook, not that your 32MB media card even dreams of audiobooks. There’s no advanced interaction; you can pause it or start it over. And here’s the kiss of death and why I don’t even launch my music player anymore: on my Cingular handset, I can’t delete or move the pre-installed carrier ringtone, which means in the middle of my tracks I hear the Cingular ringtone. Then look at the Verizon LG Chocolate, if you buy a Fergie track for $2.99 from the ringtone store you can’t put it in your music playlist. To do that you’d have to buy it again from the music downloads for another $2.99.
That said, I have a hard time believing that in the US, the iPod sales decline is due to MP3 capable phones. I’m chalking it up to the fact that the competitors are getting better and that the high iPod pricing is now more balanced with slightly lower priced competitors.
Phew, I said all that so I could say this: if it is merely a music phone — as Russel Buckley suggests — they’ve completely leaped beyond anything in the market on the music player front. (Even non-phone players like Zune included.)
But, is it a smartphone?
Some people are saying this is not a smartphone, and maybe it isn’t, by some strict definition. But in a very real prosumer sense, it stacks up very nicely against the best smartphones like Palm Treo or a the Motorola Q. When you have a mobile web implementation that makes WAP look like DARPAnet, plus push email, threaded SMS texting, calendaring, contact integration, etc. you have a smartphone.
At least that’s what David Pogue is calling it, along with calling Apple a fairy godmother. It seems that only spreadsheets (Datavis) are the obvious feature that’s not yet there. Some are arguing that the absense of a hard qwerty keypad makes a smartphone designation a stretch since thumbing text is the current accepted model.
Finally, to be fair, if Apple truly has closed the platform to third-parties then it’s very hard to call it a smartphone/PDA in the Palm/Treo/Windows Mobile tradition.
So what is it then?
Adding it all up puts it somewhere in the fuzzy, next generation hybrid media phone slash prosumer smartphone. It seems especially ripe for those who are ready to quick hauling 2 devices around and who want to adopt mobile email, mobile web browsing (and who don’t already have their thumbs tuned to a tiny qwerty keyboard). If any other product categories are an indicator, prosumer devices should do just fine as long as the right consumer-level entry aspects are there.
Bottom line for me? I have 6 months to save and let my contract expire. For me, it was either hope for the iPhone announcement or give in to the Moto Q or the next SonyEricsson. =)
94 Responses to “The Apple iPhone: Music phone or smartphone? Part III”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
While the keyboard/smartphone debate is frequently discussed , the absence of hardkeys is a much larger issue. While many times I have time to sit, focus, and dual-handedly wield my trusty Blackberry, I just as frequently fumble through my pockets, have my hands full of other doodads, or (*shhhh*) dial the phone while driving. I can’t imagine a one-handed-speed-dial-my-girlfriend-while-running-to-catch-BART on a touchscreen. I also can’t imagine scroll-wheeling my contact list while carrying a 20lb guitar case.
So the iphone seems like a grand experience for the calm, attentive, and coordinated, but if there’s one thing I’ve learned over time, it’s that mobile phone users are also mobile themselves, so the more tactile affordances (read: actual buttons) the better. And that exponentially is true for anyone who’s visually impaired.
[…] The Apple iPhone: Music phone or smartphone? Part III Apple’s foray into mobile reminds me of Apple’s iPod launch. In 2001 they were not the first music player on the scene by any means. But when they released it they blew away the competition — the click wheel, the price point for massive 4GB storage compared to the 48MB competitors reset the pricing across the category and they nailed PC syncing. […]
first financial bank…
Actual articles about first financial bank and more. …
financial management practical…
Features of financial management practical….
crab photo…
Value information about crab photo…
bones skull…
Top news about bones skull….
estate florida investment real…
estate florida investment real intro…
choose from over…
The choose from over…
shemale thumb…
Books about shemale thumb….
wayne nj real estate…
wayne nj real estate co…
download free mp3 ringtone…
Approved articles about download free mp3 ringtone….
apartment rent…
apartment rent foundation…
mercedes…
Modern view of mercedes….
weird al yankovic…
weird al yankovic info…
real estate agent austin…
real estate agent austin moves…
naruto video youtube…
naruto video youtube co…
real estate land…
Of real estate land and more…
chicago buick…
This site is about chicago buick….
detroit pontiac…
Modern view of detroit pontiac….
center guitar location…
Technologies of center guitar location…
hotel memphis tn…
hotel memphis tn intro…
white meat black treat…
Actual news on white meat black treat category….
mencia mind…
mencia mind co…
assetsimagesgawwk logo smal…
assetsimagesgawwk logo smal introduction…
small business tax advice…
small business tax advice intro…
direct mortgage marketing…
direct mortgage marketing moves…
cam dance web…
cam dance web author…
blog debonair…
Master information for blog debonair….
claim fraudulent insurance…
Actual news on claim fraudulent insurance category….
mary queen…
Latest mary queen news…
nicotine nasal spray…
Catalogue of nicotine nasal spray….
generic name for morphine…
Modern view of generic name for morphine….
ass hole fever…
Very actual information about ass hole fever….
camera photo…
This site is about camera photo….
haifa israel vacation…
–>haifa israel vacation…
celebrity century…
celebrity century info and more…
hilton head golf…
This page contains some info about hilton head golf…
credit program tax…
Intresting information about credit program tax….
car service station…
Advantages of car service station….
canada form revenue tax…
Technologies of canada form revenue tax…
roses…
roses start page…
adams apple…
Advantages of adams apple….
john douglas…
Master information for john douglas….
deed foreclosure in lieu…
home | deed foreclosure in lieu | contacts…
treo ringtone…
Fresh information about treo ringtone….
geneva ny…
Reviews of geneva ny….
700w treo…
Modern view of 700w treo….
background friendster…
Title of background friendster…
best gaming computer…
The reasons why the topics of Gaming PC is so attracting is because of the satisifaction you deprive from making your very own Gaming PC. I will not miss any information provided on your articles and do recommend anyone interest in building their own G…
bra nursing…
Pros and cons of bra nursing….
steven raichlen…
Very actual information about steven raichlen….
2 hawk tony underground…
Title of 2 hawk tony underground…
mcfarlane figure…
Top news about mcfarlane figure….
casio s770…
home | casio s770 | contacts…
mcculloch chain saw troubleshooting…
Good information about mcculloch chain saw troubleshooting….
dustop car cover…
Fresh news on dustop car cover….
box jewelry plan wooden…
home | box jewelry plan wooden | contacts…
companion lladro traveling…
Reviews on companion lladro traveling….
accent mark spanish typing…
Eye of accent mark spanish typing…
land sale vermont…
Intresting information about land sale vermont….
jaguar salt lake city…
home | jaguar salt lake city | contacts…
christiana kassab…
Relevant search results and links for christiana kassab…
swell pedal…
–>swell pedal…
dolce and gabanna dress…
homepage of dolce and gabanna dress…
columbus city map…
homepage of columbus city map…
oregon accident lawyer…
Title of oregon accident lawyer…
kent county michigan…
Master information for kent county michigan….
kim bum soo…
Top news about kim bum soo….
colorado cottage estes park…
The best of colorado cottage estes park….
asian escort in chicago…
Books about asian escort in chicago….
kingsley mi real estate…
Description of kingsley mi real estate….
home vacation wisconsin…
Value information about home vacation wisconsin…
colorado department estate real…
colorado department estate real co…
missouri crappie fishing…
News about missouri crappie fishing….
feat furtado nelly timberland…
Fresh information about feat furtado nelly timberland….
bag gucci travel…
The bag gucci travel…
columbus den lion ohio…
columbus den lion ohio intro article…
motley crue tattoo…
Info about motley crue tattoo….
dj magic mike…
homepage of dj magic mike…
gamma o…
gamma o author…
russ wernimont…
home | russ wernimont | contacts…
free printable card…
Title of free printable card…
hotel london new york…
hotel london new york info…
2007 geneva motor show…
Intresting information about 2007 geneva motor show….
rss feed reader…
Fresh news on rss feed reader….
xterra snorkel…
Reviews on xterra snorkel….
beautiful boxer…
Relevant links for beautiful boxer….
adi amin uganda…
Reviews on adi amin uganda….
competitive environment pepsi…
Fresh information about competitive environment pepsi….
contour line drawing…
contour line drawing application…
peoria help wanted…
The best of peoria help wanted….
back camel catalyst…
Research about back camel catalyst….
Now that you have your new IPHONE, what about all those songs you need to fill it with? Yes IPHONE downloading.We all love music, games ,movies,tv shows and more.
None…
None…